News   Jul 12, 2024
 1.5K     0 
News   Jul 12, 2024
 1.2K     1 
News   Jul 12, 2024
 414     0 

Toronto Crosstown LRT | ?m | ?s | Metrolinx | Arcadis

From this link, they say
There will be secure indoor bike parking at this station.
at the Mt. Dennis Station.

I'm making an assumption, that it will be NOT like this, from this link:

Bicycle parking at Rotterdam Central Station

It was built in 22 months, the underground bicycle parking facility at Rotterdam’s new Central Railway Station. It was opened in November 2013 and it has parking spaces for 5,190 bicycles.
Making it the largest of the country (to date), at just a bit bigger than the runner-up. The majority of the parking spaces can be used completely free of charge.


The entrance to the large underground bicycle parking facility at the square right in front of Rotterdam Central Station and the cycleway leading to it.

This is one of several very large parking facilities that were opened in recent years at main intercity railway stations in the Netherlands. I have shown you examples of Haarlem (2010; 5,020 spaces) and Utrecht (2014; 4,200 spaces) before. Groningen (2007; 4,150 spaces) also has a facility of a similar size.

But even relatively small towns have large facilities. Houten (2011; 3,000 spaces) is a prime example and the “bicycle apple” in Alphen a/d Rijn (2010; 1,000 spaces) also shows that the Dutch arrive by bicycle at their railway stations in very high numbers. On average in the entire country 40% of the train travellers arrive by bicycle so combining modes of travel is very common in the Netherlands. That makes it necessary for the authorities to facilitate parking all those bicycles. All these large facilities popping up around the country is not because there is a race going on to have the best or biggest facility. No, building all this is needed to face an immediate and very real bicycle parking challenge.


Festivities at Rotterdam Central Station square when the king officially opened the railway station. (13th March 2014; picture courtesy of Luke Harley.) The entrance to the bicycle parking facility is clearly visible to the left.

This facility in Rotterdam was built as part of the complete reconstruction of Rotterdam Central Station and its surroundings that was finished in 2014. The Railway Station was festively opened on 13[SUP]th[/SUP] March 2014 by King Willem-Alexander. So the bicycle parking facility was opened 4 months before the rest of the station was. It has a guarded part that you can use for a fee and an unguarded part that may be used free of charge. Electronic sensors in every single parking space detect every bike and that makes it possible that the number of available spaces per row of racks is indicated. The sensor also registers how long a bicycle has been parked and if that period exceeds one month the bicycle will be removed. The impounded bicycles are collected and you can get them back for a fee. This is to make sure people do not abandon their bicycles which would fill up the facility with unused bicycles.


The interior of the Rotterdam bicycle parking facility. Rows and rows of double stacked bicycle parking racks.

The entire facility is only one floor, so the size and thus the distances are considerable. For that reason the design is such that you can and may cycle inside the facility. Mirrors make sure people cycling can see each other, even around the corner, so that collisions can be avoided. In the video you can see that people cycle in a very moderate speed to also make sure accidents don’t happen.

A system of coloured and numbered paths make sure you find your way easily. On top of that the racks are also individually numbered and the handles of the top racks are also coloured, to make it even more easy to find your bicycle back. Using the top racks requires no real muscle power because a hydraulic system in every rack helps you lift the bicycle.

The main entrance has a number of so-called travelators (moving walkways) that make it very easy to get your bicycle underground.


The travelators (moving walkways) to enter the new facility are so easy to use that a child can do it. This whole family is about to park their bikes.

The space is brightly lit to enhance the feeling of social safety. But especially compared to the Utrecht facility this facility is clearly lacking daylight. Since the ceiling of this facility forms the station square right on top of it, I think it is a missed opportunity that no windows were added to get more daylight in. A positive point is that the ceiling is high enough to park bicycles with children’s seats attached to them in the top racks.


On this rendering the roof of the facility is opened up so you can see the exact location right in front of the main hall of Rotterdam central station (drawn transparent as well). It also gives you an idea of how big it is. To the right is the tram station and to the far left the bus station. Note the absence of private motorised traffic. It can only pass the station in the front. (Picture courtesy Jan van Helleman)

The guarded part of the bicycle parking facility has a bicycle repair workshop and this is also where you can hire an OV-Fiets, the nationwide shared bicycle system of the Netherlands. But ‘normal’ bikes can also be rented and there are lockers. It was clearly visible that the free part of the facility was used more intensively than the guarded part that requires a fee. Even though the fee is not so high, at €1.25 per day. An annual subscription will cost you € 103.=

The facility offers a direct underground access to the metro station and also to the railway station. With this new facility the station square is now completely free of parked bicycles and it looks great.

[video=youtube;zWESiQlmOC0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zWESiQlmOC0[/video]

This is what I think we will get instead:
8-7.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 8-7.jpg
    8-7.jpg
    49.9 KB · Views: 864
Last edited:
Metrolinx has said that it is interested in providing quality amenities for cyclists at Crosstown stations. I think we'll see at least a couple of new bike stations and bike lockers at most stations.
 
Why must you people be so negative? Mt. Dennis probably won't have the traffic to support bicycle infrastructure anything like Rotterdamn.

Mt. Dennis is to be a "Mobility Hub". See link.

You can download the study from this link.

At the time:

The hub is planned to be:

  • The terminus station of phase 1 of the Eglinton Crosstown Light Rail Transit (LRT) line;
  • The location of a future GO Train Station along the GO Kitchener commuter rail line; and
  • The location of a 15-bay Toronto Transit Commission (TTC) bus terminal.

And maybe a station/terminal for SmartTrack.
 
I don't think you can really make a comparison. The bike station in Rotterdam is located in their main railway station. Union Station has a facility like this but it's substantially smaller. Mount Dennis station wont be the main station for Toronto. Part of this has to do with culture. In the Netherlands, cycling is part of their culture. Everyone does it. They have developed extensive bike lanes and other amenities due to this. Toronto and Canada as a whole doesn't have such a culture. Here cars are more important and it's apparent in everything here. Look at the recent Gardiner debates as a first hand example of this. They have also extensively developed their transportation station in Netherlands and a city like Rotterdam which is smaller than Toronto has a comparable transit system to what we have here and even in some aspects surpasses what we have here.
 
Part of this has to do with culture. In the Netherlands, cycling is part of their culture. Everyone does it. They have developed extensive bike lanes and other amenities due to this.

If you look into what the Netherlands was doing back in the 60s and 70s, it's clear that the reverse is more true. Back then, they were building parking lots, widening streets, and planning urban expressways just like the rest of the western world. Following a backlash, they developed extensive bike infrastructure which led to it being an ubiquitous part of the culture, not the other way around.
 
Indeed. Much of central Amsterdam was very nearly razed for various crazed 'modernization' schemes. Same goes for Paris where there was (briefly) an effort to build a giant elevated highway along the Seine on the Right Bank; what they did get, an expressway below street level, is only now being revamped.

Obviously on many issues of urbanism Europe is way ahead of most of North America....but it's a mistake to think of it as an un-interrupted thing. The postwar era was dangerous for cities everywhere.
 
Think culture is the wrong word to use but currently one can say that they are going in the right direction while we seem to take 1 step forward and 2 steps backwards on many issues.
 
Last edited:
We're getting there slowly but surely. A mobility hub at Weston and Eglinton? Back in the day the southern 427 extension to the Gardiner was supposed to be built through here. Major progress in the way we look at transit.
 
Why must you people be so negative? Mt. Dennis probably won't have the traffic to support bicycle infrastructure anything like Rotterdamn.

I'm still trying to figure out where someone would want to bike from the Mt Dennis station. If your destination is east you'll park your bike at Keele. The only other way is up the hill to Weston. And that's some serious pedalling uphill. Not something most people would want to do.
 
I'm still trying to figure out where someone would want to bike from the Mt Dennis station. If your destination is east you'll park your bike at Keele. The only other way is up the hill to Weston. And that's some serious pedalling uphill. Not something most people would want to do.

For the people from Weston (northwest), it would be generally flat for bicyclists. To the east, I think that Caledonia would be the station to bicycle to. Going home up the hill from Keele would be a problem.
 
Given that the scheduled completion date of the Eglinton Crosstown is 2020, does anyone believe that it will be completed on time? Let's use the last possible day in 2020 as December 31. That leaves just over 5 1/2 years to complete 13 underground stations including the station at Don Mills Road as well as all of the surface stops and related electrical substations, emergency exits, and complicated engineering to link Eglinton West, Yonge and Kennedy subway stations. Also, Eglinton subway station needs to have it's platform extended 30 meters north to properly connect with the Crosstown. Any thoughts?
 

Back
Top