rpgr
Active Member
I think you should go over the plans again before going on in one post about how the lack of retail hurts it and then disagreeing with someone who said there's no pedestrian-oriented retail by replying that there'll be stores all over. There won't be an indoor mall, but what do you think "Montgomery High Street, The Piazza, The Gallery, and Simcoe Promenade" are - an outdoor lifestyle centre! Restaurants, chain stores, etc.
I'll give you the fact that the plans are all outdoor retail but that's the problem IMO. As you've complained before, all these "smart centers" aren't exactly the pinnacle of retail store fronts. I'm not a fan of "plaza" structures myself as they have a good tendency to fail and fall derelict in a very short time. The big thing is that the current retail spacing sucks. It's getting better in the future with mix use plans (i.e. condos and office buildings with retail on the 1st floor). Now we can argue the semantics on how "big retail malls kill plazas" and such but IMO for a downtown core, it is lacking character on the retail front.
Oh and if you're gonna have a quote fight, I can do that too. You complain about me at this
I think you should go over the plans again before going on in one post about how the lack of retail hurts it and then disagreeing with someone who said there's no pedestrian-oriented retail by replying that there'll be stores all over
Then in the same post you say this:
I haven't seen any plans that really address the suburban megarterial nature of both Warden and #7, yet they can't possibly tie all of Markham Centre together without doing so...if they any intention doing so.
But I'd be quoting out of context on what you mean, I can find a lot of other examples as well but I'd never expect I'd have to do that with you Scarberiankhatru (I think higher of you than that).
Maybe I wasn't clear on my meaning so here it what I want to say.
The current retail sucks in terms of where things are now and how they are spaced out. It is getting better with a lot of future building plans to include mix-use retail (be it condo or office), yet for a more "downtown" feel, I think the whole outdoor shoppe / retail front is disjointed (this is an "uptown" characteristic).
If I had to use your words to describe how i feel about it, it is this:
The "Markham Centre" plans aren't much more than guidelines for developers to turn individual vacant lands into whatever version of urban they see fit...there doesn't seem to be any overarching/overall plans that acknowledge the size of area they're attempting to change other than a regularly updated construction roundup.