News   May 17, 2024
 2.6K     3 
News   May 17, 2024
 1.7K     3 
News   May 17, 2024
 10K     10 

New Freedom Tower design unveiled

B

BuildTO

Guest
New Freedom Tower design unveiled
Wed Jun 28, 2006 1:39 PM ET


By Mark Egan and Joan Gralla

NEW YORK (Reuters) - The redesigned Freedom Tower at Ground Zero in Lower Manhattan, planned to become America's tallest building, will be a monolithic glass structure reflecting the sky and topped by a sculpted antenna, the architects said on Wednesday.

Symbolic of the Declaration of Independence, the reworked 1,776-foot centerpiece of the World Trade Center site unveiled by architect David Childs will have a base sheathed with rolled, heat-treated glass over concrete.

The tower is planned as a symbol of New York's revitalization after the September 11 attacks in 2001, which claimed more than 2,700 lives at the World Trade Center.

Rebuilding has been dogged by almost five years of acrimony over designs, security, insurance and control of the 16-acre site at Ground Zero.

The new design uses a high-tech laminated safety glass, which if attacked by a truck bomb would shatter into falling pebbles, not break into flying shards.

The previous design featured a 200-foot metal and concrete base, added after New York police said the building would be vulnerable to truck bombing. The design was also criticized for looking too bunker-like.

The new plan for the building -- construction began in April and is hoped to be completed by 2010 -- was made after consulting New York police counterterrorism experts as well as state and city officials.

The exterior glass to be used is rolled with molten metal and the design features a vertical triangular rib motif, echoed throughout the building and on the antenna.

The tower will be surrounded by groups of steps leading to the entrance, serving as a public plaza and security buffer zone. A series of thigh-high rectangular slabs on the site's perimeter -- resembling tombstones in an artist's rendering -- will guard against truck bombs.

The antenna, to be used by radio and television broadcasters, has been given a more sculptural feel by Kenneth Snelson, a sculptor best-known for his Needle Tower, installed in New York's Bryant Park in 1968.

The antenna raises the building from 1,338 feet -- the height of the original World Trade Center's 110-story twin towers -- to the full 1,776 feet.

Unlike most other glass-clad office buildings, the Freedom Tower will appear clear because they will remove the iron, which tints glass green, Kenneth Lewis of architects Skidmore, Owings & Merrill told reporters at a preview.

"We've tried to make it more monolithic," he said. "It's reflecting the sky and the changing light's character as the day goes on."

The architects have drastically rethought Daniel Libeskind's original twisting design for the Freedom Tower because it would have been too hard to build and too vulnerable to attack.
 
ATTACKS%20FREEDOM%20TOWER%20a81127bb-13b4-467f-a947-094952b6c526.jpg
 
Thanks ganja,

It looked pretty much like the previous design by SOM to me.

AoD
 
It looks okay, but SOM is capable of so much more. There is the twisting Dubai tower, or some of the SOM projects in China. At the very least, those ones are more imaginative.
 
It's a great design for a 1338 foot tower but going for 1776 feet (which really doesn't have much to do with 9/11 specifically anyway) makes it look like it's trying too hard. The antenna looks tacked on.
 
The clearer glass technology intrigues me, but the design is a bit of a snore. The World Financial Center in Shanghai is many times better than this.

www.emporis.com/en/wm/bu/?id=130957

Considering the Freedom Tower is supposed to be a marquis structure on the NYC skyline, I expected better.

The spire-like design they showed off in the past would have been better, or even a WTC-like glass box with a twist would have been nifty.
 
^^^BH - the 1776' thing merely refers to the sainted year that America gained its freedom from Britain. It's basically just more jingoistic structure to hang the name "Freedom Tower" from. I agree with elook that some other way to get to that height other than that upstretched middle finger would have been prefereable, but I think they want the tower strictly as an FU to their enemies.

42
 
Despite all of the security measures and improvements, I'm glad I'll never work in that bullseye.
 
I find the design a rather plain and surprisingly clumsy.
Making the spire base somewhat more sculptural doesn't relieve the transition between it and the rest of the building. The building top just ends too abruptly, or too flatly to incorporate it properly, with the spire back in the middle of the roof. Also, although I like the odd spire here and there on tall buildings, this one just seems like an easy jab at height, and lacking the sense of completion that carrying the building upwards might have brought.
My other complaint is with the base. It's nice that they want to do something pretty with glass on it instead of leaving it raw looking, but from the render it also looks unintegrated with the tower above it. Couldn't they have at least tailored the base so that the towers tapered corners began at ground level? That would have added some grace and drama to the design.
 
...or repeat the cube at the top again, just smaller and twisted 45%.

42
 
The clearer glass technology intrigues me, but the design is a bit of a snore. The World Financial Center in Shanghai is many times better than this.

I actually had a feeling the new Freedom Tower shape is somewhat based on the SWFC design. In fact, some of the elevations of the Freedom Tower are almost identical to the SWFC.

From Architectural Record:

060629childs2lg.jpg


060629childs3lg.jpg
 
The antenna looks ridiculous.

What, if anything, is Liebskind-designed in the revamped WTC site proposal?
 

Back
Top