General railway discussions

[roger1818]

Here's the world ship tracker. http://www.shiptraffic.net/marine-traffic/bays/Ungava_Bay

View attachment 591926

Nothing with a transponder in the Arctic beyond Greenland's shores and the North Sea today whatsoever. We clearly have a long way to go before we can justify railways to the north.

Not sure what app you are using, or options you have selected, but here is what I get. Not a massive amount of traffic, but not the barren wasteland your map shows.

 

[nfitz]

If Quebec natural resources are appropriately located, the line from Schefferville, QC could be extended to Kangiqsualujjuaq, where a port could be constructed to serve vessels in the Ungava Bay.

Wouldn't it be shorter, and likely much cheaper (with roads already in place), to build a port near Goose Bay? Which is a very natural harbour and protected bay.

The bigger issue is the almost as long gap along the North Shore.

But really - why wouldn't you just build the proposed large port east of Quebec City

 

[Urban Sky]

But really - why wouldn't you just build the proposed large port east of Quebec City

“Because then we wouldn’t have to build a new railroad just to serve that new port!”

 

[lenaitch]

There is already a proposal to lay rail from the Saguenay region to Baie Comeau.

I think Quebec likes fund studies. Makes them feel all 'nation-y'.