Toronto Union Station Revitalization | ?m | ?s | City of Toronto | NORR

Student99 said:
I was thinking of that TTC upgrade the other day. They were promising that with the automation, trains could be run "closer together", lessening the wait times. Yet with recent cuts to service, they are saying wait times will increase, as well as prices.
Click to expand...

The service reductions and the price increase are political choices, and unrelated to Automatic Train Control (the signal upgrades to which are you are referring).

Those signal upgrades were only done to Line 1, not to Line 2, 3 or 4. There is also some minor outstanding work on Line 1 for sidings and the like which may or may not have been completed yet.

Student99 said:
Makes me also wonder what happened to the promises of 15 mins service on Lakeshore East and 20 mins on Lakeshore West pre-pandemic. We got that for such a short amount of time. These are both 30 min service now post-pandemic with no indications of returning to the speedier service.
Click to expand...

Lakeshore East is currently the subject of major construction both for the Ontario Line and the LSE Corridor expansion east thereof adding a 4th track, so it's unlikely 15M off-peak will be returning there for awhile.

LSW could see it restored tomorrow if Metrolinx were given the $$ and the political push.(subject to having enough staff) Again a choice largely made at the Ministerial level; though likely recommended by Mx, partially due to lower ridership, but also to deal with staff shortages and construction.
 
Northern Light said:
The service reductions and the price increase are political choices, and unrelated to Automatic Train Control (the signal upgrades to which are you are referring).

Those signal upgrades were only done to Line 1, not to Line 2, 3 or 4. There is also some minor outstanding work on Line 1 for sidings and the like which may or may not have been completed yet.



Lakeshore East is currently the subject of major construction both for the Ontario Line and the LSE Corridor expansion east thereof adding a 4th track, so it's unlikely 15M off-peak will be returning there for awhile.

LSW could see it restored tomorrow if Metrolinx were given the $$ and the political push.(subject to having enough staff) Again a choice largely made at the Ministerial level; though likely recommended by Mx, partially due to lower ridership, but also to deal with staff shortages and construction.
Click to expand...
I guess I was implying that it just makes me wonder, why did we invest in Automatic Train Control on Line 1 if the customers aren't even going to see the benefits with higher frequency service? And perhaps we wouldn't be seeing these fare increases now if the money wasn't spent on it.
 
Student99 said:
I guess I was implying that it just makes me wonder, why did we invest in Automatic Train Control on Line 1 if the customers aren't even going to see the benefits with higher frequency service? And perhaps we wouldn't be seeing these fare increases now if the money wasn't spent on it.
Click to expand...
The previous signal system was ready to fall apart, was barely hanging on.
 
Student99 said:
I guess I was implying that it just makes me wonder, why did we invest in Automatic Train Control on Line 1 if the customers aren't even going to see the benefits with higher frequency service? And perhaps we wouldn't be seeing these fare increases now if the money wasn't spent on it.
Click to expand...

Passengers will see the benefit. Toronto is growing at ~100,000 per year; and Back to the Office mandates are just now kicking in.

Services will be back to or greater than pre-pandemic levels by sometime next year, if not a bit sooner.
 
Student99 said:
I guess I was implying that it just makes me wonder, why did we invest in Automatic Train Control on Line 1 if the customers aren't even going to see the benefits with higher frequency service? And perhaps we wouldn't be seeing these fare increases now if the money wasn't spent on it.
Click to expand...
Much of the Line 1 signaling was 50 years old and was becoming VERY expensive and complicate to repair. As with all 'physical plant' one needs to evaluate whether something is worth repairing or whether, in the longer term, it would be cheaper to replace it. There is also often the problem that it is virtually impossible to buy spare parts for old equipment. Of course, one also needs to look at whether a newer technology will actually do MORE than the current: the new signaling on Line 1 was a "YES" from both perspectives.
 
Student99 said:
I guess I was implying that it just makes me wonder, why did we invest in Automatic Train Control on Line 1 if the customers aren't even going to see the benefits with higher frequency service? And perhaps we wouldn't be seeing these fare increases now if the money wasn't spent on it.
Click to expand...
TTC won’t provide a breakdown but ATC was also implemented to save on conductor cost. TTC employees are paid pretty well and halving the labour cost per train results in decent savings over time. They were running service far above demand over COVID/post-COVID which is probably what necessitated the fare increase and service reductions.

I think there isn’t enough focus on operations at the TTC. The raw service levels on the TTC is actually very good, the issue is you’ll frequently see bunching and bad headway management resulting in wait times far above the service standard, then 2 busses/streetcars arrive consecutively. Part of that is just a reality of a surface transit network and partially it is poor operational capabilities. A couple years ago when I regularly took the 504, there’s a TTC supervisor that stands at the corner of King/Dufferin recording when each streetcar passes by in the morning. In an age of live location tracking and multiple cameras throughout the train, it was quite surprising to see such a basic task still being done by pen/paper, which probably limits the amount of analysis/planning they do with that data.
 
trtcttc said:
TTC won’t provide a breakdown but ATC was also implemented to save on conductor cost. TTC employees are paid pretty well and halving the labour cost per train results in decent savings over time. They were running service far above demand over COVID/post-COVID which is probably what necessitated the fare increase and service reductions.

I think there isn’t enough focus on operations at the TTC. The raw service levels on the TTC is actually very good, the issue is you’ll frequently see bunching and bad headway management resulting in wait times far above the service standard, then 2 busses/streetcars arrive consecutively. Part of that is just a reality of a surface transit network and partially it is poor operational capabilities. A couple years ago when I regularly took the 504, there’s a TTC supervisor that stands at the corner of King/Dufferin recording when each streetcar passes by in the morning. In an age of live location tracking and multiple cameras throughout the train, it was quite surprising to see such a basic task still being done by pen/paper, which probably limits the amount of analysis/planning they do with that data.
Click to expand...

Can we kindly move this to the TTC catch all thread?

https://urbantoronto.ca/forum/threads/ttc-other-items-catch-all.20264/page-984
 
union2pearson said:
If anyone cares, Patties Express will be at Union Station shortly, perhaps late April, early May. Fresh Market to open shortly around the same time.
Click to expand...

Many of us do indeed care; and thanks for the update!
 
union2pearson said:
Look for Adaria Micromarket concept to begin construction shortly in the bus terminal on the upper level.
Click to expand...

For those not in the know, this is an un-staffed retail concept. Sometimes vending-machine forward, sometimes not.

1680289929255.png


From: https://adaria.ca/services/micromarkets/market-designs
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top