Richard White
Senior Member
Well, yeah. It's not actually completed.
but but.. John Tory said...
Well, yeah. It's not actually completed.
Because the delay of Union Station was an embarrassment to the city.Ya why were we in a rush to announce completion of Union Station? This is embarrassing.
Five years later, still inconsistent UP Express wayfinding.
View attachment 338537
View attachment 338540
View attachment 338538
I was testing the wayfinding by trying to have my daughter find the airport train. So many signs only say UP which is ridiculous. Thankfully there seems to be some realization that the picture of an airplane is an important detail. Still, none of these align to the wayfinding standards created by Metrolinx with an overly detailed airplane showing flaps, or a GO engine of a certain model and time.
I'm not even a big Wayfinding nerd/purist, but the Union Station signage just seems so lazy.
No doubt explained by the fact that the 'complex' has many owners and operators who clearly do not communicate as much as would be desirable!
As a concrete example, I find the signage directing commuters to the "York Concourse" and the "Bay Concourse" to be completely useless.
Ah yes - odd they phrase it the way they did. I hadn't realized that it was still the same name back when it carried the tracks eastern out of Union.
Terminated at York in the 1924 Fire insurance maps - https://www.toronto.ca/city-governm...re-insurance-plans/fire-insurance-plans-1924/
The western section was rebuilt when the Dome was built: Bremner Blvd. was called The Esplanade West originally. I guess it was renamed when it dawned on the City that it made no sense as it would never be connected to the eastern half under the rail corridor.
Following the Mayor's somewhat premature announcement that "Union station is completed", I wrote to him asking about some of the "minor' bits and pieces we have been wondering about. Rather to my surprise, I got a reply.
- Repairs to the Great Hall floor – The City expects this work to be completed by end of 2022
- Installation of lighting in the Great Hall – The City expects this work to be completed by end of 2022
- Repairs to the Front St Promenade ceiling – The City expects this work to be completed by the first quarter of 2022
- Turning on the external heritage lighting – The City expects this work to be completed by September 2021
I think they should’ve renamed the concourses East and West, especially since the future South concourse is hopefully not “Lakeshore concourse” or “Bremner Concourse”. When people ask for directions, they usually don’t understand what “walk towards York street” means relative to where they are in the station, especially because York is not a prominent street until you get south of Front.The wayfinding here drives me absolutely nuts. I don't use Union Station on a regular basis, but I've been in the facility dozens of time. Half the time I'm in there I end up getting lost. And I know I have a really good sense of direction, so if I'm getting lost in there, it must feel like an unnavigable labyrinth to someone from out of town that might not be directionally inclined.
As a concrete example, I find the signage directing commuters to the "York Concourse" and the "Bay Concourse" to be completely useless. They might be useful if you're someone intimately familiar with the facility, but as someone who rarely uses the station, these names are completely meaningless to me. What the heck is the "Bay Concourse"? How is anyone that doesn't use this station on a regular basis supposed to know what that is? I don't know what the Bay Concourse is, and honestly I don't care to know. Just tell me where to go to find my trains. That is my singular goal. Where is my train!?
And yea, the UPX signage is completely unacceptable. I couldn't give a damn about the "UP Express" branding, all I care about is getting to the Airport. The only thing these signs need to say is "Train to Airport" with a pictogram of an airplane. Simple, clear and straightforward.
I think 'by the end of 2022" means that that sub-project is in the budget for 2022 so it may happen much sooner. And is more likely to happen faster if we continue to bug the City and its staff!My thanks, as always for you diligent efforts!
- Begrudging ......ok.....sure...
-Exasperation............another 9.5 months to get a comparatively small section of ceiling plastered and painted!
- About time; yay!
Just back from a stroll and can report that "they' are testing and adjusting the external heritage lighting (so they may actually be turned on as promised!). Also, the work on the Platform 3 'bridge' over Bay seems to be finishing. They have removed the construction shielding and seem to be starting to dismantle the scaffolding.
Platform 3 is also closed!Just remember this exterior cladding will be serving as the interior wall of the new bridge linking the station to CIBC Phase II. So things are far from done.
AoD
Platform 3 is also closed!