If the needs of the Faculty of Architecture, Landscape and Design can be met in a three-storey pavilion added to the north side of the old Knox College building, why would they want to go larger/taller there? Two reasons stand out for me:
1) The Faculty should have a building that is identifiably theirs to anyone passing by. "That's the U of T Architecture Building" said Craig as he toured his friends quickly through the campus, hoping to get to Guu before the line-up got crazy.
Not having to share a larger building with other faculties is very helpful in creating a sense of belonging and ownership for both students and fac.
2) We're talking about a Gothic revival building that has looked down Spadina Avenue for 137 years. Do we really want to compromise the vista from the south significantly? Too much of our heritage is altered beyond recognition or gone entirely already. That said, I'm looking forward to some needed restoration and minimal modern insertions into the building's public realm.
The north side has never been more than parking lot and shabby afterthought additions, and it distinctly feels like an unloved back-side. Transforming it into something boldly contemporary is rather exciting. It has been a complete waste of a vista point in this city from that side. NADAAA certainly has some fascinating designs in their portfolio, and that teaser of a rendering above has me anticipating what is to come.
42