Toronto Richmond Adelaide Centre: EY Tower | 188.05m | 40s | Oxford Properties | Kohn Pedersen Fox

Shadow Weaver said:
Love this building, but I do wish it was taller. Toronto is hightist! Why is Toronto afraid of shadows?

Oh and the Sapphire Tower was gorgeous and should have been built.
Click to expand...

I will say this: It was tacky, but big-city. To have been realized would have been a feat, and we'll never know how it would have looked. But what we do know is what was built played it safe, and is forgettable as a result.

Yes, I would have loved to see EY done taller, but I understand why shadows need to be addressed, specifically at this location. Just bad luck from a height point of view that our Financial District is in City Hall's front door with not much room in either direction.
 
The Sapphire Tower would've probably looked like the HNR or Velocity or whatever tower. At least in terms of quality. A design like that is almost guaranteed to look atrocious in this city.

As for this tower, I actually agree that it would've looked better taller but with a caveat. I feel the design doesn't match the site. The building would look far better stretched out, maybe another 50-100m. But, I also agree wholeheartedly with Council's desire to avoid excessive shadowing on NPS. With that in mind, I'd say it's the developer's failure to see that this design would be so stumpy looking and their failure to not look for a more suitable design for this site and the height limit imposed.

Edit: Also, despite my complaints about this one being stumpy, I don't care too much. It's pretty ugly from some angles (though hopefully the crown on this one will help) but the restored heritage building is really well done and totally makes up for what might be an uglier (though far from ugliest) office tower.
 
Cell phone shot from last night

IMAG0710.jpg
 

Attachments

  • IMAG0710.jpg
    IMAG0710.jpg
    1.7 MB · Views: 3,794
March 19
I see they have most of the existing brick, stone work and artwork backup on the new building and looks good

Lot more up on site
26016414885_2fda14d08c_b.jpg

25921474961_f1b9384569_b.jpg

25383687494_5f3528c12e_b.jpg
25990094536_e5641f6c18_b.jpg

25387290573_45a018c835_b.jpg

25387285543_f140828fb0_b.jpg

25387294823_16d55a3665_b.jpg

26016073885_4443bb074e_b.jpg

25383353704_1fac522bb5_b.jpg

26016105825_0e03b508ec_b.jpg

25990181116_a2edd856bd_b.jpg
 
wolfewood said:
Goddamn does the rebuild look good!
Click to expand...
A huge thank you and Job well done for those who worked on the project at least the heritage portion. fantastic! I now see why the new portion is shaped the way it is... And where they got their inspiration from of the details on the heritage parts near top and those "mountain" shapes. Bravo team EY and can't wait for the top to be done cause right now the angle is throwing me off. It does not appear to match the render... But the seems a steeper more upright angle the say the 45 degree I had thought it appeared in its render. Still thinking it will. Look good it her way mind you.
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top