Hmmmm,.... that sounds like a challenge.
I've done an inventory of all bank branches and credit unions (excluding ATM, money-marts, curency exchange shops, specialized investments shops, etc,...) for the two areas.
Bay Street from Bloor to the Gardiner Expressway is 3.1km. I've expanded the Yonge Street area originally from 401 to Finch to Henden/Bishop Ave (just one block north of Finch) so that it would also be 3.1km.
LEGEND:
< on west side of street
> on east side of street
*** CREDIT UNION
B# Bank count
CU# CreditUnion count
Inventory for "Uptown Yonge Street" between 401 and Hendon-Bishop Ave (just one block north of Finch)
B1 < RBC 5700 Yonge Street - North American Life Tower - Yonge & Hendon southwest corner - formerly at 5460 Yonge
B2 < TD 5650 Yonge Street - Xerox Tower - Yonge & Finch northwest corner
B3 > Scotiabank - Yonge & Finch northeast corner
B4 < BankOfMontreal - 5522 Yonge (south of Tolman/Finch - New - just opened)
B5 < TD - 5400 Yonge Steet
CU1 < *** DUCA - 5290 Yonge Street
B6 > CIBC - 5255 Yonge Street
B7 < HSBC - North York City Centre north tower - Yonge & ParkHome/Empress southwest corner
B8 < BankOfMontreal - North York City Centre south tower - Yonge & ParkHome/Empress southwest corner
B9 > Shinhan Bank - EmpressWalk - Yonge & ParkHome/Empress southeast corner
B10 > Scotiabank - EmpressWalk
B11 > RBC - 5001 Yonge Street
B12 < Korea Exchange Bank - Madison Centre
B13 > BankOfMontreal - Sheppard Centre - north tower
B14 > TD - Sheppard Centre - mall lower level
B15 > CIBC - Sheppard Centre - south tower
B16 > TD - 4685 Yonge Steet - north of Avondale
Total:
16 Banks
1 Credit Union
These 2 banks are in projects that are currently under construction - they could be new branches or branches being relocated
> RBC - Tridel-Hullmark Centre
< unnamed major bank in EmeraldPark
Inventory for "Downtown Bay Street" between Gardiner Expressway and Bloor Street
B1 < TD - Bay & Bloor southwest corner
B2 > BankOfMontreal - Bay & Bloor southeast corner
CU1 < *** Meridian - Desjardin Credit Union - Bay & Wellesley northwest corner
CU2 < *** Alterna Savings - Bay & College northwest corner
B3 < CIBC - Bay & College southwest corner
B4 > TD - 777 Bay Street - Bay & College southeast corner
B5 > BankOfMontreal - 763 Bay Street
B6 > CIBC - Bay & Dundas northeast corner - AtriumOnTheBay mall lower level
B7 < TD - Bay & Queen southwest corner
B8 < Scotiabank - Bay & Richmond northwest corner
CU3 > *** Meridian - Desjardin Credit Union - Bay & Richmond southeast corner
B9 < ICICI Bank - 350 Bay Street
B10 < BankOfMontreal - Bay & King northwest corner - First Canadian Place
B11 > ScotiaBank - Bay & King northeast corner - ScotiaPlaza
B12 < TD - Bay & King southwest corner - Toronto Dominion Tower
B13 > CIBC - Bay & King southeast corner - Commerce Court
B14 < SBI (State Bank of India) Canada - Bay & Wellington northwest corner
B15 < RBC - Bay & Wellington southwest corner
B16 > TD - Bay & Front northeast corner - Brookfield (BCE) Place - TD Canada Trust Tower
Total:
16 Banks
3 Credit Union
If we're only counting the bank branches,... then we have a tie,.... both area has 16 bank branches. If we include credit union, then downtown Bay Street would lead since it has 3 credit unions whereas uptown Yonge Street only has 1 credit union.
Even though it's a tie for the number of bank branches in the area,.... the downtown Bay Street area has the huge flagship bank branches of the big 5 banks whereas the uptown Yonge Street area has the JoeBlow regular bank branches. Also, the downtown Bay Street area has other bank branches to the east along Yonge Street and to the west along University Avenue,... the uptown Yonge Street area only have bungalows, McMansions and condos to the east and west of Yonge Street.
What's interesting, in the next few years,... as new bank branches open up, the Uptown Yonge street could have more banks than dowtown Bay Street. There's an RBC branch that's going into Tridel-Hullmark Centre when it finishes next year and another major bank (unnamed) going into EmeraldPark. I don't know if these will be brand new branches or relocated branches. Also, there are other development projects in the uptown Yonge Street area whereas downtown Bay Street is basically already built up. Some uptown Yonge street projects like GibsonSquare, Sorbara group and the Centrium with Korean mall are great locations for bank branches.