Tuscani01
Senior Member
21st Century version of Chrysler Tower?
Philly already claimed that:
Source: https://www.phillymag.com/foobooz/2014/12/18/one-liberty-place-getting-observation-deck-restaurant/
21st Century version of Chrysler Tower?
Built in 1987.Philly already claimed that:
Source: https://www.phillymag.com/foobooz/2014/12/18/one-liberty-place-getting-observation-deck-restaurant/
Built in 1987.
We also have a couple in North York
Comparing 80s Murphy/Jahn to 00s Kirkor will get you far - New York to North York far. The latter is so atrociously out of proportion and cheap that they should make it a pilgrimage site for would be architects as to what *not* to do.
AoD
I think that North York's examples are perfectly fine for what they are--a middle class community of suburban condos. They're some of the few residential towers along the 401 in the 416 that are memorable, distinctive, and playful. By contrast, I would hold an office tower in the CBD to a considerably higher standard.
There is playful - and then there is horribly executed pastiche. I wouldn't want to wish NY Towers on anyone - even the suburbs.
AoD
There is playful - and then there is vacuous pastiche with the added sin of horrible execution. Nevermind the non-starter that something of its ilk belong to the CBD - I wouldn't want to wish NY Towers on anyone - even the suburbs.
Vacuous pastiche they may be, but in many ways I'd happily take them over most of the grey-blue clumsy spandrel box buildings being built downtown in this boom. These may not be very graceful but they create variety in form and at least attempt some kind of architectural expression.
The solution to the mundane and the mediocre isn't garbage.
AoD