News   Aug 07, 2024
 34     0 
News   Aug 07, 2024
 256     0 
News   Aug 07, 2024
 224     0 

Star: (Hume) 'Poetic' Vision for Jewish Memorial CANCELLED (Libeskind)

A

AlvinofDiaspar

Guest
From the Star:

'Poetic' vision for Jewish memorial
Nov. 7, 2006. 07:33 AM
CHRISTOPHER HUME

Though memorials commemorate the past, they must also address the future.

Few take that responsibility more seriously than the Jewish War Veterans Memorial. Designed by celebrated architect Daniel Libeskind, he of the Michael Lee-Chin Crystal addition at the Royal Ontario Museum, this is a work that looks ahead to a world that doesn't yet exist.

When finished a year from now, the piece will tell a story that has never been told. Located on a .8-hectare site in the northwest corner of Earl Bales Park near Bathurst and Sheppard, Libeskind's monument will be a thoroughly 21st-century hybrid; not only consecrated ground but also part sculpture and part architecture, a destination as well as an event space.

"It will be a place of celebration and a place of meditation," explains Libeskind, who first came to international prominence in 2000 with the remarkable and deeply moving Jewish Museum in Berlin.

"It speaks about those who fought and died fighting for freedom. It has to be intimate but also monumental. It has to be appropriate but also accessible."

The $6 million project, which will break ground next spring, consists of a large curvilinear structure — in Libeskind's words, a "shield" — that swoops dramatically to a point more than 15 metres above the ground. Its stainless steel surface is punctuated by nothing except eight slits, each one lit from within.

Most striking of all is an enormous pointed element — a "sword" — that pierces the shield. The tip will be illuminated — by an eternal flame.

Facing the main structure is an amphitheatre with seating for 250 people. The stage in front of them forms the bottom corner of the shield. Encircling the amphitheatre are two walls on which the names of the veterans are etched. Like the main structure and the sword, these walls will be clad in stainless steel.

As Libeskind makes clear, light will play a major role in the memorial. Each name will be backlit so that at night the memorial will take on a different character.

Libeskind hopes the results will be "poetic."

The eight lights on the big piece and the eternal flame are meant, Libeskind says, to evoke the hanukkiah and the shamash, which together form the nine-armed candelabra that symbolizes "the fight for democracy, freedom and justice."

Though construction of the memorial won't start for months, a model made by Sohiel Mosun, a Toronto custom fabricator and design-build firm known for its high quality work, has recently been completed. It lays out the scheme in amazing detail, though as Darius Mosun points out, many elements remain to be worked out.

"Every time I look at the model I'm blown away," says Lou VanDelman, executive director of the memorial foundation. "We still have to complete the fundraising but that won't be a problem. Already it has caught the imagination of Jewish veterans around the world. This is an international memorial; it's not just for Canadian veterans. Though most of the veterans fought in Word War II, it's for veterans of all wars.

"The myth is that Jews didn't fight in World War II," VanDelman adds. "We fought, and in greater numbers proportionally than any other group. In fact, two of every three eligible Jewish men in Canada enlisted during the Second World War. Nobody knows about their stories; these people have a legacy to leave and they haven't left it. There's a long history of Jews in the Canadian military."

So far, veterans from 38 countries will have their names inscribed in the walls. Organizers expect to add more names annually; there's room for more than 20,000. Their stories will be available on a website organized for the memorial.

The site was important, VanDelman says, because it's quiet, acoustically protected and within walking distance of the Holocaust Memorial, just south in Earl Bales Park.

"We wanted a site where there's no activity," he says. "And where it's pitch black at night. The city has bent over backwards to give us the land."

The project has also been an enormous source of pride for the people at Sohiel Mosun; they got involved relatively early in the process and have collaborated closely with Libeskind to ensure that the finished product meets expectations.

Staff has travelled to New York on numerous occasions to discuss issues such as the route of the path that leads to the memorial, the paving and the exact kind of stainless steel; it should gleam but can't be too shiny. In the end, three types of brushed steel were chosen, though that, too, could change.

"It's been a great honour to be involved in this project," Libeskind says happily.

"There's nothing else like it anywhere in the world."

AoD
 
Jewish veterans memorial in Earl Bales scrapped
By RON CSILLAG, Special to The Canadian Jewish News
Wednesday, 14 January 2009

TORONTO — The Jewish War Veterans of Canada’s (JVW) much-heralded memorial to Jewish soldiers, planned for Earl Bales Park, will be scrapped after years of inactivity.
A scaled-down version is slated to be built on the grounds of the Bathurst Jewish Community Centre, the veterans say, adding that they’re still fundraising.

The Toronto Post of the JWV admits that it’s in disarray following a shake-up last year of its leadership. But the veterans say a memorial of some kind to Jews who served in the armed forces will be built.

However, it will bear little or no resemblance to the project that was planned and widely publicized in 2005: an ambitious $7-million work of art to have been built by world-renowned architect Daniel Libeskind and dubbed Flames of Memory.

Set back from Bathurst Street on two acres of land donated by the City of Toronto, it was envisioned as a sweeping, curved structure resembling a chanukiyah that gradually ascended five storeys, topped by eight lights. Slicing through the middle was an arrow-like structure that would act as an eternal flame.

The project also called for a sunken amphitheatre to seat up to 200 people, ringed by two walls, one inscribed with names of Jewish war veterans from around the world, and the other to carry the names of battles in which Jews have fought, including those in Israel. The flags of 30 Allied nations and insignia of the various Canadian armed forces were to have flown.

Ground for the memorial was broken in October, 2005 in front of cabinet ministers, MPs, senators, MPPs, army and police brass, as well as Toronto Mayor David Miller, who called the project “the most significant war memorial erected in Canada in 50 years.â€

All that is now history, says Toronto councillor Mike Feldman, in whose ward, York Centre, the memorial was to have been built.

“It’s pretty well scrapped,†Feldman told The CJN. The veterans “weren’t able to raise the money.â€

He called the project “overly ambitious.â€

The City of Toronto “was prepared to go ahead. But in order to protect the taxpayer, it had to have certain conditions met. [The Jewish war veterans] couldn’t meet those conditions, because their fundraising was a bust.â€

Former JWV executive director Lou Van Delman said that since the project was launched, only about $700,000 of the $7 million has been raised, with most of that going for engineers, seed money and to pay Libeskind for his work to date.

The campaign included raising money for a $2-million endowment fund for maintenance and upkeep.

A sign soliciting funds for Flames of Memory still stands after more than three years in the north end of the park.

Feldman said the city has asked the JWV to take it down.

A new memorial is planned for the grounds of the Bathurst JCC, said the chair of the Toronto Post’s board, Morey Eckler.

“It won’t look the same [as the original]. I don’t think it will be even close to what [Libeskind] proposed.â€

Eckler said whatever money was raised for the project is in an escrow account, but he didn’t know how much that is. “We can’t find the records.â€

He said the Toronto Post has experienced “difficulties†since Van Delman and former Toronto Post commander Hy Shulman were ousted last year.

In the meantime, “we’re in the midst of getting rid of bad feelings in the community. It’s a big job.†The veterans are still soliciting donations, he added.

Feldman said he would like to see the JWV Toronto Post and the General Wingate Branch of the Royal Canadian Legion get together on a single project. “To have two separate groups is ridiculous.â€

He said this episode has left him “very disappointed,†adding that the project’s failure is “embarrassing for the Jewish community.â€

Arthur Drache, an Ottawa lawyer who specializes in tax law, said the JWV, as a registered charity, is entitled to keep whatever money it has raised to date.

“The money goes to the charity, not the project. The funds were not rased under false pretenses.â€

Neither Libeskind nor Toronto Post commander Norm Gardner were available for comment.
 
^^ I second that motion UD..Libeskind is overrated and under-talented. Eisenman is a Jew, so let's tap him for the next round and leave Libeskind on the lecture circuit where he belongs...

p5
 
No, I am not. Not sure if you have ever had the chance to work with him, but he is a great speaker, but not much of an architect...

p5
 
I believe these are accurate.

Jewish%20War%20Veterans%20Memorial4.jpg


Jewish%20War%20Veterans%20Memorial3.jpg


Jewish%20War%20Veterans%20Memorial2.jpg


Jewish%20War%20Veterans%20Memorial1.jpg
 
I'd still cut it slack. And besides, out in Earl Bales, it would've been harmless.
 

Back
Top