I loved the Village, I thought it was his best work, This movie...had no twist, and I agree with #5, but he fit the part well. And I don't remember the critic coming back to life in a later scene.
Sixth Sense was alright- although it didn't really make sense in places. His other movies were pretty bad- especially Unbreakable which was just plain rediculous. I can imagine Paul Giammatti is regretting choosing this one.
