News   Dec 17, 2025
 267     0 
News   Dec 17, 2025
 290     0 
News   Dec 17, 2025
 614     0 

Arch Record: Shopping Malls Not Below Libeskind's "Dignity"

wyliepoon

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
2,011
Reaction score
3
http://archrecord.construction.com/news/daily/archives/081016libeskind.asp

Shopping Malls Not Below Libeskind's "Dignity"
October 16, 2008

By C. J. Hughes

After a decade of creating jutting projections for museums, Daniel Libeskind has attempted to redefine the look of another institution: the shopping mall.

Called the Westside Shopping and Leisure Centre, the low-slung 1.5-million-square-foot facility in Bern, Switzerland, is the first project of its type for the New York-based architect. It opened on October 8.

Like many of its mid-20th-century suburban American counterparts, Westside features known international retailers strung along enclosed corridors, with 70 stores across three levels, as well as a compact 10-restaurant food court (McDonald’s and Starbucks included). Also on the property, which lies on the city’s western edge, is an attached 144-room hotel and 11-screen cinema, both designed by Libeskind.

Moreover, the $440 million complex offers an 18-pool water park called Bernaqua Adventure Pool and Spa. At 575 feet, one of its three outdoor slides is Switzerland’s tallest, according to developer and grocery chain Migros Aare, which is an arm of Migros, the country’s largest employer.

Instead of locating the mall far from residential neighborhoods, Migros is attempting to create a residential enclave around it. Already standing on the property is a two-building, 95-unit senior complex, designed by Libeskind. Eventually, it will be joined by 800 new apartments on surrounding land, according to Franzisca Ellenberger, a Westside spokeswoman.

Details of the mall’s physical appearance, too, seem a departure from tradition. Corridors are laced with diagonal trusses and enough sharply angled and gleaming surfaces to suggest the facets of a gemstone. Windows, many of them triangular, funnel ample natural light into hallways that otherwise might have been bathed in fluorescence; they also provide views of cow-dotted green pastures. Also unexpected, perhaps, is the facade’s dark-brown robinia wood, lined vertically like paneling.

Instead of being adrift at the end of a vast parking lot, like so many contemporary shopping centers, Westside sits on top of A1, a busy highway. Though there are 1,275 parking spaces, the mall also has a commuter train stop, which can be reached from downtown Bern in eight minutes.

The pools at Westside will typically stay open until 10 p.m., movies could get out as late as 2:30 a.m., and concerts are planned for a permanent stage inside the mall. In these ways, Westside could become a round-the-clock social center, which might further help redefine its larger function, Libeskind says. “Architects for a long time thought malls were below their dignity,†Libeskind says. “But if you bring nature and culture into the building, you can make it a radically different place.â€

1.jpg


2.jpg


3.jpg


4.jpg


5.jpg


*****

I like the swimming pool, but I don't think the mall interior is anything special- I'd take Yorkdale or Fairview over this mall in terms of interior design any day. Still better looking than Vaughan Mills, though.
 
I quite like it. You can tell he was really still in his crystal design phase when he designed this.

I like the roadway under it, and the pools. I love the sharp lines, and the dark glass crystal portions running through the sides.
 
Low ceilings are what differentiate a good mall from a great one and that mall is suffering from that problem. Let's not compare any mall to Yorkdale that's probably not fare (It's probably one of the most sucessfull malls in North America is it not?).

I think the mall does look cool though but I guarantee you in 20 years people will be saying why the hell did they build that. Even now it does seem a bit old with the limited open space and lots of concrete (or whatever that material is.
 
Boring and irrelevant. That is what comes to my mind. It is time for Libeskind to find a new shtick.
 
Here's the scribbly little sketch / sketchy little scribble:

http://www.e-architect.co.uk/switzerland/jpgs/westside_shopping_leisure_center_sdl200907_dl_sk1.jpg

From a 2003 interview with designboom:

Q: Can you describe an evolution in your work from your first projects
to the present day?

DL: I still think I'm doing the same project,
its all the same project
.

The video on the Studio Daniel Libeskind site suggests that they relied more on poured concrete than at the ROM, where steel was king:

http://www.daniel-libeskind.com/projects/show-all/westside-shopping-and-leisure-centre/
 
Low ceilings are what differentiate a good mall from a great one and that mall is suffering from that problem. Let's not compare any mall to Yorkdale that's probably not fare (It's probably one of the most sucessfull malls in North America is it not?).

The low ceiling is not the big issue (in fact I do like the galleria-like qualities of the interior). Rather it has to do with the choice of materials and colours for the interior. It actually looks like a cheap imitation of some of the mega-malls that have been recently built in the Middle East or East Asia.
 
The last thing a mall needs is to appear to be confusing on the inside. For me, the best malls are reasonably roomy, clean and easily accessed barns with welcoming stores lining long, attractive halls. Indoor malls are at their best when they successfully rip-off outdoor pedestrian mall experience, and when they make you forget that you are inside what amounts to a storage hangar that is surrounded by an ocean of parking.

Since there appears to be major renovations on big mall interiors every decade or so, that fixed, over-structured look evident in the interior photos shown would, I think, be eventually modified or ripped out.
 

Back
Top