News   Apr 20, 2026
 651     0 
News   Apr 20, 2026
 445     0 
News   Apr 20, 2026
 1.1K     3 

Ontario Northland/Northern Ontario Transportation

Thinking about the return of the Northlander, there is a scenario where it may flop - the rolling stock they decided on. Everyone may be worried about winter. I am thinking of overnight. The former Via Northland service, IIRC had sleepers of some sort. This one, while running similar to the Northland schedule does not. So, while it may be on the right schedule, the lack of any real sleeping options besides the chairs, that may cause it to not do as well.
 
Thinking about the return of the Northlander, there is a scenario where it may flop - the rolling stock they decided on. Everyone may be worried about winter. I am thinking of overnight. The former Via Northland service, IIRC had sleepers of some sort. This one, while running similar to the Northland schedule does not. So, while it may be on the right schedule, the lack of any real sleeping options besides the chairs, that may cause it to not do as well.
Do the seats recline? That's all I need for a relatively short overnight train. I took the VIA once from Toronto Calgary and slept in my seat.
 
I tried doing this on The Ocean once. Do NOT recommend it.
It was 1987, I was 16 and broke. I brought a jar of jam and a loaf of bread and ate that for three days straight from Toronto to Calgary, lol. The things we do when we're young.
 

He is turning out to be a decent MP. From what I have heard, he isn't a far right conservative. He was someone who supported the former liberal MP, Serre.

It was 1987, I was 16 and broke. I brought a jar of jam and a loaf of bread and ate that for three days straight from Toronto to Calgary, lol. The things we do when we're young.
Would you do it the same way today, in your condition and age? You are the younger end of the target ridership for travel on the Nothlander.
 
can we move the conversation from improvements to REPLACEMENT? im not sure why we have to continually scrape more seconds out of a 70 year old relic instead of actively finding suitable new replacements?
 
Would you do it the same way today, in your condition and age? You are the younger end of the target ridership for travel on the Nothlander.
As long as the seats recline it's no worse than a premium economy flight from Toronto to Asia. Emirates gold class aside, no one is offering you a curtained off berth on a 18-hour flight to Taiwan, so I don't expect it on a 10-12 hour train ride from Timmins to Toronto. I don't see why we expect rail service to give us a bed when air service does not. Best part about rail traffic is the ability to get up and move around easily.
 
As long as the seats recline it's no worse than a premium economy flight from Toronto to Asia. Emirates gold class aside, no one is offering you a curtained off berth on a 18-hour flight to Taiwan, so I don't expect it on a 10-12 hour train ride from Timmins to Toronto. I don't see why we expect rail service to give us a bed when air service does not. Best part about rail traffic is the ability to get up and move around easily.
I'll be interested to hear from people like you to see whether that sentiment still holds. Remember, planes tend to find smoother air to avoid turbulence. That is not as easy on a train. Hopefully though much of that roughness has been mitigated on the line.
 
Total ridership (on/off) for the year was 6,964. Source: VIA Rail


I still believe this train needs to be extended West to Thunder Bay. There is more of a market to generate year round ridership with the addition of Marathon, Terrace Bay, Schreiber, Nipigon, Shuniah, a few First Nation communities, and last, but certainly not least, Thunder Bay.
The current White River service is a day train. What is more likely to work out in the event of an extension to TB - a Jasper-Prince Rupert overnight stop in White River, or operating at night? Folks between Thunder Bay and White River might be cheesed off if they end up with an unsocial hours limited stop service while the communities east of White River get daytime flag stop service. And where's the tourism potential in transiting the shore of Superior at night?
 
The current White River service is a day train. What is more likely to work out in the event of an extension to TB - a Jasper-Prince Rupert overnight stop in White River, or operating at night? Folks between Thunder Bay and White River might be cheesed off if they end up with an unsocial hours limited stop service while the communities east of White River get daytime flag stop service. And where's the tourism potential in transiting the shore of Superior at night?
The issue you run into is due to various things, White River may not be able to support that kind of train. This comes down to hotels and restaurants.
 
When the Northlander did run did ONR crews stay in a Hotel in Toronto and then depart the next day? If service is only 3 days a week, how is that going to work
 
As long as the seats recline it's no worse than a premium economy flight from Toronto to Asia. Emirates gold class aside, no one is offering you a curtained off berth on a 18-hour flight to Taiwan, so I don't expect it on a 10-12 hour train ride from Timmins to Toronto. I don't see why we expect rail service to give us a bed when air service does not. Best part about rail traffic is the ability to get up and move around easily.
The difference of course being that there is no viable alternative way to get to Taiwan, so people need to suffer through whatever accommodation they can afford. To get from Timmins to Toronto is only a 1h20 flight, so for the train to be competitive among people who could afford the flight, it needs to be much more comfortable.
 

Back
Top