SaugeenJunction
Senior Member
MSF from the sky
The $2B is for the tunneled portion.$2B for two lanes through "downtown" Brampton is ludicrous.
I count 16 cars in the yard up from the 4-6 I saw in February as they were on the tow north tracks only and nothing next to the carhouse. Either some been moved out doors or more have arrived since then.. There are supposed to be 27 for opening day.
The last figure in 2025 was $2.9 Billion From Steeles to Wellington with Wellington to Nelson being over $2 Billion. What it will be after it is tender as well when will be higher since the bidders will be dealing with ML how has a poor track recorder and hard to deal with on P3 contracts. Mobilinx will not be part of either tender considering both were part of the original tender and removed from the contract at the time of signing. How the tender will work for the 30 year contract with ML current contract will be interesting but the operation will be done by Mobilinx as an extra to the their contract.
Those words are copy of Brampton folks that have used them here and elsewhereThe City of Brampton has never broken it down in writing by describing it as "From Steeles to Wellington" and "Wellington to Nelson" when it comes to the cost estimate. The cost estimate is for the entire 3.8 km length, as shown in multiple City staff reports on the City's website. Your wording is incorrect and not Brampton's.
During any EA studies, options and technology is looked looked at for a project like this with the TBM being part of it. Brampton rule out the TBM due to the extraction hole being in the centre of Main St which would mean the street is close south of Wellington for years as there isn't a location elsewhere where it could be place. there was a suggestion that the TBM could be removed sideway into the land on the west side being clear for development and the removable of the old creek structure, but would require a cut and cover of the road and sidewalk to do that.October 28, 2015 - Council voted against the main street portion through downtown Brampton - Stopping the line at Steeles instead of continuing downtown
Feb 2017 - Council directed staff to study alternative routes into downtown Brampton - This is when McLaughlin Road and Kennedy road were made suggestions
May 22, 2019 - Council approved the EA to reconsider the extension - This update brought Main/George and tunneling back onto the table, while aslking staff to take a look at Kennedy road and McLaughlin road as well.
June 23, 2021 - Council received the preferred alignment report and directed both preferred options forward to 30% design - Council moved forward with the main street surface and tunnel options, shelving the Kennedy road and the McLaughlin Road alignments
May 10, 2023 - Council received the 30% design updated and directed more talks with ML and the province - The project remained focused on the Main Street Alignment and tunnel/surface choices.
Sources:
1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/brampton-transit-vote-lrt-1.3291894
2. https://pub-brampton.escribemeetings.com/filestream.ashx?DocumentId=27563
3. https://pub-brampton.escribemeetings.com/filestream.ashx?DocumentId=81975
4. https://www.brampton.ca/EN/resident...ents/HMLRT-Brampton-Alignment-Peer-Review.pdf
The old guard that lived in downtown Brampton wanted to preserve the downtown area and was not willing to accept an at grade LRT because of the historic core. They wanted a tunnel, or an alignment on McLaughlin road or Kennedy road as alternatives. These were people who do not take transit at all. They thought seeing a LRT on the road would hurt their property values.
Another bloc wanted to prioritize locking in a fully provincially funded ready-to-build main street alignment, and feared they were going to lose the money and regional network benefits (they lost both).
Sources:
1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/brampton-transit-vote-lrt-1.3291894
2. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/brampton-lrt-plan-tunnel-1.4943343
3. https://spacing.ca/toronto/2015/10/30/bramptons-short-sighted-hurontario-main-lrt-decision/
When people make suggestions about extending the line East/West, you need to understand that this has already been studied. The costs of these studies and not settling on the Main Street alignment meant that the funding that would have gone to it as the approved-by-the-province funding was no longer there.
We lost a decade over these alignments. I'm not about to suggest we lose another decade extending it and having the costs balloon significantly more for alignments that do not have any transit hubs.
Downtown Brampton being transit centric means the inclusion of the LRT in the corridor to move just as many people as the 502/501/561 and other Brampton Transit buses / GO buses / Trains do. Brampton does not have the space as of late to do both. The downtown core moves a significant amount of vehicle traffic, as well as transit users. Theatre Lane / Nelson / George are single lane / two lane roads at points that are not equipped to move traffic to create a pedestrian centric downtown core as of yet.
Those words are copy of Brampton folks that have used them here and elsewhere
Brampton 2023-03-29
The 30% Preliminary Design and Draft EPR’s identified that both thesurface and the tunnel options are technically feasible and each comeswith its own distinct benefits and costs. The underground option issignificantly more costly ($2,804M) compared to the surface option($933M). However, the underground option also provides real travel timesavings for transit riders, pedestrians, cyclists, and motorists and allowsthe City to achieve its vision for Main St and Downtown Brampton whilelimiting risks for implementation and operation, compared to the surfaceoption
Start Date: September 2024
End Date: December 2027
The City of Brampton is starting the Downtown Brampton Streetscape work along Main Street (between Nelson Street and Wellington Street) and Queen Street (between Mill Street and Chapel Street).
During any EA studies, options and technology is looked looked at for a project like this with the TBM being part of it. Brampton rule out the TBM due to the extraction hole being in the centre of Main St which would mean the street is close south of Wellington for years as there isn't a location elsewhere where it could be place. there was a suggestion that the TBM could be removed sideway into the land on the west side being clear for development and the removable of the old creek structure, but would require a cut and cover of the road and sidewalk to do that.
Any cut and fill for the tunnel section north of the creek is out of question as it will cause the same mess as a TBM and more. This leaves mining as the only option for the tunnel section from the southside of the creek to the station.
The tunnel only starts just south of the creek where the portal will be to the surface and then on the surface to Steeles.
Service to the downtown is between 2031-35 depending getting design from 30% to 100% to go to tender or when ML goes out with an RFP for a P3 that will do the 100% design work as well build the line
In 2024, Brampton was calling for two lanes of traffic and bike lanes is opposite to what they were saying at the beginning of the EA and were not willing to loose two lanes for the LRT.
Any east-west line is outside my scoop with an BRT being the best option from my point of view.
The line will open in 2028.