Toronto 355 Sherbourne | 42.08m | 12s | United Property Resource Corporation | KPMB

ferusian

Active Member
Member Bio
Joined
Oct 21, 2019
Messages
443
Reaction score
2,737
355 SHERBOURNE ST
Ward 13: Toronto Centre

Development Applications

Project description:
Official Plan and Zoning By-law amendment for a 12-storey mixed-use building, including the retention of the existing place of worship on the lot. 1494.10 square metres of non-residential floor area is proposed, for a total non-residential floor area of 3123.0 square metres. A total of 8149.00 square metres, and 100 rental residential dwelling units are proposed.

This is the site of St Luke's United Church (completed 1887):

1624749205441.png


1624749218198.png


Aerial view:

1624749379271.png
 
355 SHERBOURNE ST
Ward 13: Toronto Centre

Development Applications

Project description:


This is the site of St Luke's United Church (completed 1887):

View attachment 330626

View attachment 330627

Aerial view:

View attachment 330628

Interesting!

The building is not individually designated; only as part of the Cabbagetown Heritage Conservation District.

The original building dates from 1876/86 (depending on source)

From reviewing the exterior, it was clear there is more than 1 generation of building here.

TO Maps reveals that too, with 3 distinct municipal addresses and overlapping footprints.

1624750976159.png


1624751002375.png


The 'porch' and south wing were added in 1960
My take is that they could be sacrificed if the original building is fully intact and restorable.

As per the below:

1624751424729.png

This is taken from:

Toronto Architecture: A City Guide
by Patricia McHugh and our own @AlexBozikovic

Which I highly commend as a great resource! It was the most information I could find on the building's history.

*****

So this frontage on Sherbourne is all 1960:

1624751579734.png


This is the rear of the south wing visible from alley at the eastern limit of the property via Streetview:

1624751713875.png


I'm not clear on when the rear (east portion) of the building was added, but it doesn't read as original to me, though it certainly reads as older than 1960.

1624751654808.png


Assuming you wanted to retain the core heritage building.......

This (below) looks like a developable footprint:

1624751864530.png


It gives you ~11,500ft2 of footprint.
 
Last edited:
More info:

UPRC St Luke's Media Release - FINAL-June 24 2021

St. Luke’s United Church Redevelopment Underway

TORONTO ( JUNE 24, 2021) — United Property Resource Corporation (UPRC) is planning a mixed-use redevelopment for St. Luke’s United Church in downtown Toronto. The proposed redevelopment of the historic site preserves and revitalizes the 1887 heritage sanctuary and includes a new mid-rise addition that would feature mixed income and affordable rental housing, as well as dynamic community and cultural spaces. The site is located in Ward 13 (Toronto-Centre) at the southeast corner of Sherbourne and Carlton Streets directly across from Allan Gardens.

UPRC is a community-building developer working coast to coast to build inclusive and sustainable communities across Canada.

“Our approach is to explore options for mixed income and affordable rental housing. We do this while considering heritage as well as understanding and appreciating the needs of the community," said Tim Blair, CEO, UPRC. "We are committed to this process as a community-building developer. We believe that vibrant neighbourhoods are vital for all Canadians and that we can play a role in building these in Toronto and across the country."

About St. Luke’s

St. Luke’s has been at the heart of the Cabbagetown/Allan Gardens community for generations, open to serving the needs of all citizens and groups living in the area. This development looks to restore the original 1887 footprint of the Church starting with restoring St. Luke’s Square as a welcoming threshold to the new and enhanced community spaces at the first two levels.

The existing sanctuary and cultural spaces are to be restored and made flexible while additional community spaces able to support the diverse needs of the broader community will be added.

To date, consultations have taken place with over 70 community and special interest groups and more will continue as the project progresses.

The new 10 storey residential component will provide 100 units (163 bedrooms) with 70% market rental as well as 30% affordable rental housing, aligned with Toronto’s housing standards to accommodate more families. The massing defers to the Church, its towers, and Allan Gardens as it steps up and wraps the site to the south and west to express the towers and avoid adding shadows on Allan Gardens. The residential entrance and lobby are on Carlton Street entering directly into the restored heritage building. Multiple terraces have views back to the Church and across Sherbourne Street to Allan Gardens.

The project, which is being led by KPMB Architects, will be designed as a high-performance building anticipating the sustainability needs of the coming decades. It will utilize PassiveHouse levels of performance to target zero on-site carbon emissions leading to a healthier, more comfortable building for its users and the surrounding community.

“How wonderful to repurpose a significant heritage building and make way for a diversity of uses on the site to address the critical needs of our time; inclusivity, adaptability and sustainability,” commented Marianne McKenna, Founding Partner KPMB Architects.

About UPRC

United Property Resource Corporation (UPRC) is a community-building developer that works to create mixed income and affordable rental housing across Canada. UPRC’s affordable housing approach is designed to increase opportunities for individuals, including Indigenous Peoples, Black People, People of Colour, Seniors, Women, and members of the LGBTQ2S+ community to access safe, healthy, and adequate homes. UPRC and its partners are working to create socially, environmentally, and financially sustainable communities through development projects that will promote the common good for the next 100 years. For updates on UPRC’s projects please visit www.uprc.ca.

StLukesHeroE1280.jpg
StLukesStrNE1280.jpg
StLukesStrSE1280.jpg


42
 
That's pretty close to the footprint I suggested, except they went further north at the west limit of the property.
 
I can hear the Cabbagetown residents sharpening their "neighbourhood character" spears ask we speak...
...it will probably be how this will "gentrify" the neighbourhood made by those who are already gentrified. /sigh
 
It's so much better than what's there now. Those additions to the church look clumsy and take away from the beauty of the original structure. This will eliminate those add-ons, create a much wider public realm between the church and road while animating what was a bit of a dead zone. A win all around.
 


353-355 Sherbourne Street and 157 Carlton Street - Official Plan and Zoning Amendment Application - Preliminary Report


This item will be considered by Toronto and East York Community Council on November 24, 2021.

Summary
This report provides information and identifies a preliminary set of issues regarding the application located at 353-355 Sherbourne Street and 157 Carlton Street. The subject property is located on the southeast corner of Sherbourne and Carlton streets.

The application proposes a 12-storey (42 metre) mixed-use building containing 100 rental residential units (8,149 square metres of residential gross floor area), of which 30% would be affordable housing, as well as 3,123 square metres of community space. The proposal would entail the removal of two components of the existing St. Luke's United Church (the narthex and gymnasium) while retaining the rest of the building. No vehicular parking spaces would be provided. A privately owned publicly accessible space is proposed on the Sherbourne Street frontage.

Staff are currently reviewing the application. It has been circulated to all appropriate agencies and City divisions for comment. Staff will proceed to schedule a community consultation meeting for the application with the Ward Councillor.​
 
Issues list:

• The appropriateness of a "tall building" at the subject property;
• The appropriate degree of conservation of built heritage attributes at the site
• The relationship of the proposed built form relative to retained built heritage resources at the site and adjacent to the site, as well as potential shadow, privacy and overlook, and other massing impacts of the built form onto adjacent non-heritage- designated properties;
• Ensuring no net new shadow onto Allan Gardens;
• Impact on Neighbourhoods-designated areas south-east and north-west of the site;
Exploring opportunities to incorporate parking into the site, which may impact the built form; and
• Improving access to sunlight for outdoor amenity spaces provided

Ugh. I mean, a lot of these issues aren't actually issues and it's just planning being the little sticklers they are and not allowing an appropriate, creative project, but demanding parking? really?
 

Back
Top